Hey Reader,

Since I’ve mentioned my New York trip in the last couple of newsletters, I thought it was time for a trip report. This week, I’m sharing the five hotels I visited.

Of course, there are a ton of luxury hotels in Manhattan, and I already have a list of hotels to visit on my next trip. But for this first foray, I chose a mix of price points, vibes, and neighborhoods.

Here are a few thoughts and impressions on each, in the hopes that this gets you started if you’re planning a trip to the Big Apple.

Aman New York

If I had to sum up the Aman in one word, it would be exclusive. The bar, restaurant, and spa are only for guests, residents, and members, so despite being right on 57th and 5th, it feels remarkably quiet inside. Rooms are large and have beautiful bathrooms—some rooms even have floor-to-ceiling windows—and there’s a spectacular spa. The minimalist decor may not feel as “New York-y” as some of the other hotel options, but it’s perfect if you prefer a calm, retreat-like experience and some excellent elbow-rubbing.

Waldorf Astoria New York

This one just feels like New York. Occupying an entire midtown block, it reopened in 2024 after an eight-year renovation that took 1,400 rooms down to 375 (plus a similar number of residences). They’ve done a beautiful job of preserving the history while modernizing everything. And I particularly loved how much a part of the city it feels: people come in and out, meet by Queen Victoria's clock in Peacock Alley—it really feels like a gathering place. Yes, it’s big and busy, but it also offers the largest spa in the city and spacious, quiet rooms. If you like to feel like you’re in the thick of it, the Waldorf is for you.

The Fifth Avenue Hotel

As soon as I walked into this NoMad hotel, I thought of La Fantaisie in Paris or Casa Monti in Rome, and it turns out it’s the same designer—it has that same intimate, cozy, residential vibe. By coincidence, I had dinner at their restaurant the evening before my site visit, and the food and ambience were great. The bar is apparently very hard to get into, which tells me locals are using it—always a good sign. This is a great pick for design, atmosphere, and something stylish in a good, central-but-not-Midtown location.

Crosby Street Hotel

I have friends who always stay here when they’re in town, so I was excited to finally visit (their afternoon tea has also been on my list forever). Designed by British interiorist Kit Kemp, it’s got an artsy, eclectic vibe that I think fits Soho perfectly, but it’s still cozy and comfortable. Rooms are light-filled, the restaurant is lively, and there’s a private lounge with an honor bar that’s just for guests. This one has a lot of character, a boutique feel, and a great Soho location.

The Greenwich Hotel

Popular with repeat guests, The Greenwich is in a quiet part of Tribeca and feels very residential. It’s owned by Robert De Niro, who’s filled the hotel with art from his family’s personal collection, as well as gorgeous tiled bathrooms, warm wood details throughout that reminded me of a Tuscan villa, and a Japanese-inspired spa. The restaurant, Locanda Verde, is technically independent and was full of locals when I visited. If you want something residential and off the beaten path with a neighborhood feel, it’s a great option (and it would be perfect if you’re in town for the Tribeca Film Festival, which is headquartered next door).

---

Next week, I’ll share more of what I did, places I ate, and some of the things I like to recommend for visitors.

What else would you like to know about New York? Want a neighborhood rundown? Curious about a hotel you think I should check out when I’m back in the fall? Need some restaurant or activity recommendations? I really do love hearing from you, so hit reply and let me know!

P.S. Did you know I offer complimentary hotel bookings? I have over 4,500 preferred hotel partners around the world, so you get the same rate you’d find online but with extras like room upgrades, property credits, and early check-in when available. If you’ve got a trip coming up, book your VIP stay here.